Manuscript Progress

 

         Check the progress of a manuscript by finding its assigned number in the first column and then reading across for the latest information about its progress through the review process. The journal uses a two-tier review procedure. Manuscripts are first reviewed by the Editor for appropriateness of content and overall quality appropriateness of content and overall quality and appropriateness for this journal. Manuscripts that are not appropriate for the journal or that have obvious and major flaws are rejected without additional review. Next, a manuscript can be assigned to one of the Associate Editors (Keith Markman, Ohio University; Brad Sagarin, Northern Illinois University) or will be handled by the Editor (Robert Arkin, Ohio State University). Both members of the Editorial Board and other experts in the field are then selected and asked to provide a scholarly appraisal of the work. Ordinarily two reviews are sought; occasionally, additional reviews may be requested for manuscripts that report complex methodology or that cover topics spanning many content areas. Manuscripts with an "R" designation (see below) are revisions.

Manuscript
Number

Date
Received

Reviews
Received

Decision
Date

Action Editor

Comments

31-12-08 12/31/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
30-12-08 12/30/2008 0   Arkin  
29-12-08 12/30/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
28-12-08 12/28/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
18-12-08 12/16/2008 1   Arkin  
17-12-08 12/17/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
16-12-08 12/16/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
15-12-08 12/14/2008 0   Arkin  
14-12-08 12/14/2008 2 2/28/09 Arkin  
13-12-08 12/13/2008 0 1/12/2009 Arkin  
10-12-08 12/10/2008 0 1/14/2009 Arkin  
08-12-08 12/8/2008 1   Arkin  
03-12-08 12/12/2008 2 4/20/2009 Arkin  
27-11-08 11/27/2008 0 1/9/2009 Arkin  
24-11-08R 4/20/2009   4/23/2009 Arkin Accepted
24-11-08 11/24/2008 1 4/2/2009 Arkin  
22-11-08 12/16/2008 0 1/14/2009 Arkin  
21-11-08 10/13/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
20-11-08 11/20/2008 0   Arkin  
18-11-08 11/18/2008 1 3/26/2009 Arkin  
14-11-08 11/14/2008 2 2/28/09 Arkin  
11-11-08 11/10/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
10-11-08 11/10/2008 1   Arkin  
06-11-08 11/13/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
05-11-08 11/19/2008 2 4/2/2009 Arkin  
04-11-08 11/14/2008 1 3/26/2009 Arkin  
03-11-08 11/10/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
01-11-08 11/1/2008 3 4/1/2009 Arkin  
28-10-08R 3/10/2009   3/26/2009 Arkin Accepted
28-10-08 10/28/2008 2 12/31/2008 Arkin  
23-10-08 11/10/2008 2 4/14/2009 Arkin  
21-10-08 10/21/2008 1 2/5/2009 Arkin  
20-10-08 10/20/2008 2   Sagarin  
13-10-08R   2 4/1/2009 Arkin Accepted
13-10-08 10/13/2008 1 2/5/2009 Arkin  
11-10-08 10/11/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
10-10-08R 4/2/2009   4/7/2009 Arkin Accepted
10-10-08 10/10/2008 2 2/28/09 Arkin  
09-10-08 10/8/2008 0 10/20/2008 Arkin  
07-10-08 10/6/2008 2 2/13/09 Arkin  
06-10-08 10/6/2008 1 3/26/2009 Markman  
01-10-08 10/1/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
29-09-08 9/29/2008 2 12/5/2008 Arkin  
28-09-08 9/28/2008 1 2/5/2009 Arkin  
26-09-08 9/26/2008 0 10/22/2008 Arkin  
25-09-08 9/25/2008 0 10/20/2008 Arkin  
24-09-08 9/24/2008 3 4/1/2009 Arkin  
23-09-08 9/26/2008 2 12/28/2008 Arkin  
19-09-08 9/19/2008 2 4/10/2009 Sagarin  
17-09-08 9/15/2008 2 3/20/2009 Sagarin  
16-09-08 9/16/2008 3 12/31/2008 Arkin  
15-09-08 9/15/2008 1 4/20/2009 Arkin  
13-09-08R 4/17/2009   4/23/2009 Sagarin  
13-09-08 9/12/2008 2 3/26/2009 Sagarin  
12-09-08 9/12/2008 1 3/12/2009 Markman  
11-09-08 9/11/2008 1 2/5/2009 Arkin  
09-09-08R 3/1/2009   3/26/2009 Arkin Accepted
09-09-08 9/9/2008 1 2/5/2009 Arkin  
08-09-08 9/8/2008 0 10/22/2008 Arkin  
07-09-08 9/7/2008 0 10/1/2008 Arkin  
06-09-08 9/5/2008 2 12/10/2008 Arkin  
05-09-08 9-5-2008 1 2/3/2009 Arkin  
04-09-08 9/4/2008 2 3/11/2009 Markman  
03-09-08 9/3/2008 2 11/1/2008 Arkin  
02-09-08 9/2/2008 2 11/24/2008 Arkin  
01-09-08 9/1/2008 3 3/26/2009 Arkin  
30-08-08 8/29/2008 2 11/16/2008 Arkin  
29-08-08 8/29/2008 2 2/3/2009 Arkin  
27-08-08 8/26/2008 2 12/31/2008 Arkin  
26-08-08 8/26/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
21-08-08 9/2/2008 2 3/20/2009 Sagarin  
20-08-08 8/18/2008 3 2/3/2009 Arkin  
19-08-08 8/19/2008 2 3/26/2009 Markman  
18-08-08 8/18/2008 1 2/3/2009 Markman  
16-08-08 8/14/2008 1 1/16/2009 Markman  
15-08-08 8/21/2008 2 3/12/2009 Sagarin  
14-08-08 8/14/2008 0 9/18/2008 Arkin  
13-08-08R 4/20/2009     Sagarin  
13-08-08 8/13/2008 2 3/11/2009 Sagarin  
12-08-08 8/12/2008 2 3/11/2009 Markman  
09-08-08 8/9/2008 2 12/16/2008 Arkin  
08-08-08 8/8/2008 2 12/31/2008 Arkin  
06-08-08 8/6/2008 1   Sagarin  
05-08-08 8/5/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
28-07-08 7/28/2008 1   Arkin  
26-07-08 8/12/2008 1 2/28/09 Markman  
25-07-08 7/24/2008 2 3/26/2009 Markman  
24-07-08 7/24/2008 2 3/26/2009 Arkin  
22-07-08 7/22/2008 2 10/22/2008 Arkin  
21-07-08 8/5/2008 2 3/11/2009 Sagarin  
20-07-08 7/21/2008 2 12/10/2008 Arkin  
16-07-08 7/16/2008 1   Sagarin  
15-07-08 7/15/2008 1 2/3/2009 Arkin  
14-07-08 7/14/2008 2 2/3/2009 Markman  
13-07-08 7/18/2008 2 1/11/2009 Markman  
10-07-08 7/10/2008 2 12/16/2008 Arkin  
01-07-08R     2/3/2009 Markman Accepted
01-07-08 7/1/2008 2 2/3/2009 Markman  
28-06-08 6/27/2008 2 11/12/2008 Arkin  
27-06-08R 2/19/2009   3/26/2009 Arkin Accepted
27-06-08 6/27/2008 2 12/17/2008 Arkin  
26-06-08 6/26/2008 2 9/17/2008 Arkin  
22-06-08R 2/11/2009 1   Arkin  
22-06-08 6/22/2008 2 12/10/2008 Arkin  
19-06-08 6/19/2008 2 9/17/2008 Arkin  
18-06-08 6/18/2008 2 2/13/2009 Markman  
16-06-08 6/16/2008 2 12/10/2008 Arkin  
13-06-08 6/13/2008 2 12/10/2008 Markman  
12-06-08 6/12/2008 2 12/10/2008 Arkin  
06-06-08 6/5/2008 2 9/12/2008 Arkin  
05-06-08R 2/18/2009   3/26/2009 Arkin Accepted
05-06-08 6/4/2008 2 12/16/2008 Arkin  
03-06-08R 3/11/09   3/25/2009 Arkin Accepted
03-06-08 6/3/2008 2 12/16/2008 Arkin  
31-05-08R 2/26/09   3/4/09 Sagarin Accepted
31-05-08 5/31/2008 2 12/16/2008 Sagarin  
24-05-08 5/24/2008 2 3/11/2009 Sagarin  
20-05-08 5/20/2008 2 11/12/2008 Arkin  
16-05-08 5/16/2008 2 12/10/2008 Arkin  
13-05-08 5/13/2008 3 11/12/2008 Arkin  
30-04-08R   2 3/25/2009 Arkin Accepted
18-04-08RR 4/20/2009   4/23/2009 Arkin Accepted
18-04-08R 11/18/2008 2 4/1/2009 Arkin  
17-04-08R     4/2/2009 Sagarin Accepted
17-04-08 4/17/2008 2 2/28/09 Sagarin  
16-04-08 4/25/2008 0 7/11/2008 Markman  
09-04-08 4/17/2008 3 8/12/2008 Arkin  
08-04-08 4/8/2008 2 9/17/2008 Sagarin  
05-04-08 3/27/2008 2 10/26/2008 Arkin  
04-04-08 4/4/2008 2 8/20/2008 Arkin  
02-04-08 4/2/2008 2 11/1/2008 Arkin  
01-04-08R 10/13/2008 0 11/14/2008 Arkin Accepted
17-03-08 4/4/2008 3 8/12/2008 Arkin  
10-03-08 3/10/2008 2 12/8/2008 Sagarin  
22-02-08 3/20/2008 2 8/11/2008 Arkin  
22-02-08R 10/12/2008 2 11/30/2008 Arkin Accepted
20-02-08 2/29/2008 3 8/6/2008 Arkin  
31-01-08 2/12/2008 2 7/18/2008 Sagarin  
28-01-08R 8/5/2008 0 8/12/2008 Markman  
25-01-08R 9/1/2008 0 11/3/2008 Arkin Accepted
25-01-08 1/31/2008 2 8/6/2008 Arkin  
22-01-08R 2/1/2008 3 11/24/2008 Arkin Accepted
21-01-08 1/21/2008 2 10/19/2008 Arkin  
17-01-08 2/8/2008 2 8/6/2008 Sagarin  
08-01-08R 1/1/2009 0 3/25/009 Sagarin  
07-01-08 1/18/2008 2 8/6/2008 Markman  
27-12-07 1/4/2008 2 8/8/2008 Arkin  
17-12-07 12/27/2007 3 8/6/2008 Arkin  
30-11-07R 6/25/2008 0 8/6/2008 Arkin Accepted
20-11-07R 6/3/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
10-11-07 11/10/07 2 10/19/2008 Arkin  
07-11-07R 7/25/2008 1 11/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
31-10-07 11/9/2007 1 8/13/2008 Arkin  
31-10-07R 6/6/2008 1 8/3/2008 Arkin Accepted
30-10-07R 6/18/2008 0 8/6/2008 Arkin Accepted
26-10-07 11/9/2007 7/11/2008 Sagarin  
26-10-07R 10/1/2008 2 11/25/2008 Sagarin Accepted
23-10-07R 6/30/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
19-10-07R 6/18/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
15-10-07R 12/12/2008 2 4/10/2009 Sagarin Accepted
13-10-07 10/19/2007 1 8/12/2008 Arkin  
12-10-07 10/19/2007 8/6/2008 Arkin  
09-10-07RR     4/1/2009 Sagarin Accepted
09-10-07R     3/25/2009 Sagarin  
09-10-07 10/19/2007 2 7/18/2008 Sagarin  
07-10-07R 7/11/2008 0 8/19/2008 Arkin Accepted
27-09-07R 5/15/2008 0 8/6/2008 Arkin Accepted
25-09-07 10/2/2007 2 11/10/08 Arkin  
22-09-07RR 6/25/2008 0 7/11/2008 Sagarin Accepted
14-08-07R 5/13/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
13-08-07R 8/12/2008 2 4/14/2009 Arkin  
08-08-07RR 3/28/2009   4/14/2009 Arkin Accepted
08-08-07R 7/1/2008 2 2/3/2009 Arkin  
02-08-07R 8/21/2008 0 10/24/2008 Arkin Accepted
26-07-07R 5/21/2008 0 8/6/2008 Arkin Accepted
25-07-07R 6/30/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
09-07-07R 6/25/2008 0 8/6/2008 Arkin Accepted
04-07-07R 6/10/2008 0 8/6/2008 Arkin Accepted
13-06-07R 7/23/2008 0 8/5/2008 Arkin Accepted
31-05-07R 6/10/2008 2 11/2/2008 Arkin Accepted
29-05-07RR 5/12/2008 0 6/17/2008 Sagarin Accepted
23-05-07R 6/6/2008 2 2/3/2009 Arkin Accepted
22-05-07R 5/20/2008 3 11/19/2008 Arkin Accepted
20-05-07 7/23/2007 4 8/6/2008 Arkin  
19-05-07R 7/18/2008 0 8/5/2008 Arkin Accepted
15-05-07R 7/18/2008   11/24/2008 Sagarin Accepted
08-05-07R   2 4/14/2009 Arkin  
19-04-07R 6/3/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin Accepted
05-04-07R 5/30/2008 0 7/25/2008 Arkin  
05-04-07 6/28/2007 2 3/18/2008 Arkin  
03-04-07 6/28/2007 2 1/25/2008 Arkin  
28-03-07 5/18/2007 2 4/17/2008 Arkin  
28-03-07R 9/14/2008 2 2/2/2009 Arkin Accepted
23-03-07 6/28/2007       Withdrawn
03-03-07RR 4/20/2009     Sagarin  
03-03-07R 1/21/2009 2 4/14/2009 Sagarin  
12-02-07 7/23/2007 2   Arkin  
14-01-07R 6/18/2008 0 8/5/2008 Arkin Accepted
04-01-07R 3/16/2009   3/25/2009 Arkin Accepted
12-10-06R 8/12/2008 0 8/14/2008 Oleson

Accepted

15-10-06RR 4/01/2008 0 5/20/2008 Oleson Accepted
21-10-06R 10/18/2006 0 9/4/2007 Oleson Accepted